An organisation has strong detective controls in its payment environment, including transaction monitoring and daily log review, but a recent fraud incident showed that the fraudulent transactions completed before anyone could intervene. Senior management asks the information security manager what control characteristic should most influence the next round of control design. Which characteristic should drive the design?
- AWhether the control produces a complete and tamper-evident audit trail suitable for later forensic investigation.
- BWhether the control can be implemented at the lowest unit cost across the payment environment.
- CWhether the control can prevent the undesired action from occurring rather than only reporting it after the fact. Correct
- DWhether the control reduces the average time to detect anomalous transactions across all monitored channels.
Why A is wrong: A robust audit trail aids investigation and is valuable, but it remains a detective and corrective aid; it would not have stopped the transactions, which is the gap management is asking about.
Why B is wrong: Cost-efficiency matters in control selection, but choosing the cheapest control without addressing the prevention gap would repeat the failure the incident exposed, so it is not the driving characteristic here.
Why C is correct: The incident shows detection alone arrived too late, so the design priority is a preventive control that stops the action before completion, directly closing the timing gap the fraud exploited.
Why D is wrong: Faster detection is an improvement, yet the scenario shows transactions completing before any human response, so even rapid detection would not have prevented the loss the way a preventive control would.