Marcus dies leaving an estate of 4,000,000 dollars. His will directs 3,000,000 dollars into a trust that must pay all of its income to his surviving wife Elena, a United States citizen, at least annually for her life, with the capital passing at her death to Marcus's two children from his first marriage. Elena may not withdraw capital and has no power to decide who receives it. The executor wants the 3,000,000 dollars to qualify for the federal estate tax marital deduction in Marcus's estate. What is the correct position?
- ANo marital deduction is available, because Elena's income interest ends at her death and the terminable interest rule denies a deduction wherever the property then passes to somebody else
- BThe full 3,000,000 dollars qualifies automatically, because the trust pays Elena all of its income at least annually for life and no other person may receive anything from it while she lives
- CA deduction is available only if the trust gives Elena a general power to appoint the whole fund to anyone she chooses, including her own estate, that being the single route around the terminable interest rule
- DThe executor may elect qualified terminable interest property treatment on a timely filed Form 706, deducting the full 3,000,000 dollars in Marcus's estate and including the trust in Elena's estate at her death Correct
Why A is wrong: The terminable interest rule is the correct starting point and does deny the deduction on the face of the will, which makes this tempting, but the rule carries an exception the executor can claim by election, so the outcome is not settled by the trust terms alone.
Why B is wrong: Those two features are genuine conditions of the exception, which is why this reads as complete, but qualification is never automatic for a life income trust; without an affirmative election on the estate tax return the interest stays terminable and the deduction is lost.
Why C is wrong: A general power of appointment trust is a real route to the marital deduction, so the mechanism named here exists, but it is not the only route and it would let Elena divert the capital away from Marcus's children, destroying the purpose of his plan.
Why D is correct: The election converts a non-deductible terminable interest into a deductible one, and the price of the deduction is that the whole trust is brought back into Elena's taxable estate when she dies rather than escaping transfer tax in both estates.