A CFP professional works as a registered representative of a broker-dealer and is not an investment adviser representative. A retail client aged 58 asks whether to move 90,000 dollars of taxable savings into a bond fund, and the CFP professional recommends a specific fund and earns a commission on the purchase. No financial planning engagement has been signed. Which statement best describes the standard of conduct that governs this recommendation?
- ABecause the transaction is a brokerage recommendation rather than advisory work, the care obligation of Regulation Best Interest governs it and CFP Board's fiduciary duty is not engaged.
- BCFP Board's fiduciary duty attaches once a written financial planning engagement is signed, so until then this stand-alone product recommendation is governed by Regulation Best Interest alone.
- CThe recommendation is Financial Advice, so CFP Board's fiduciary duty applies to it, and Regulation Best Interest applies to the same recommendation because a broker-dealer is recommending a security to a retail customer. Correct
- DThe fiduciary duty of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 governs the recommendation because a CFP professional giving securities advice for compensation is treated as an investment adviser.
Why A is wrong: Tempting because Regulation Best Interest is genuinely the securities standard for a broker-dealer recommendation, but CFP Board's fiduciary duty is imposed by the certification, not by registration status, so a regulatory standard cannot switch it off.
Why B is wrong: Tempting because the Practice Standards do turn on whether Financial Planning is being provided, but the fiduciary duty is triggered by Financial Advice, which is a wider category than a financial planning engagement.
Why C is correct: Correct because the two standards operate on different sources of authority and both are capable of reaching one act. CFP Board imposes a fiduciary duty at all times when a CFP professional provides Financial Advice, and Regulation Best Interest reaches the broker-dealer recommendation.
Why D is wrong: Tempting because the adviser fiduciary duty is the best known one, but it attaches to investment advisers and their representatives, and this person is a registered representative relying on the broker-dealer relationship instead.