Estelle Brandeburg files single for 2024 with modified adjusted gross income of 240,000 dollars and net investment income of 30,000 dollars. The single threshold for the Net Investment Income Tax is 200,000 dollars. On which amount is her 3.8 percent Net Investment Income Tax imposed?
- AOn 40,000 dollars, the full amount by which her modified adjusted gross income exceeds the threshold.
- BOn 240,000 dollars, her entire modified adjusted gross income for the year.
- COn 70,000 dollars, the sum of her net investment income and the excess of modified adjusted gross income over the threshold.
- DOn 30,000 dollars, the lesser of her net investment income and the excess of her modified adjusted gross income over the threshold. Correct
Why A is wrong: The excess over the threshold is one of the two amounts compared, but the tax applies to the lesser of that excess and net investment income, and here net investment income of 30,000 dollars is smaller.
Why B is wrong: The tax never applies to total modified adjusted gross income; it is limited to the lesser of net investment income and the excess over the threshold, so taxing the whole figure greatly overstates the base.
Why C is wrong: The base is the lesser of the two figures, not their sum; adding net investment income to the threshold excess incorrectly combines amounts that the statute tells you to compare.
Why D is correct: The tax base is the smaller of net investment income (30,000 dollars) and the excess of modified adjusted gross income over the threshold (40,000 dollars), so 30,000 dollars is taxed at 3.8 percent.