An S corporation shareholder has positive stock basis at the start of the year and also holds a direct loan made by the shareholder to the corporation. During the year the corporation passes through a net operating loss that exceeds the shareholder's stock basis but not the combined total of stock and debt basis. Under the basis ordering rules, against which basis must the shareholder absorb the excess loss?
- AAgainst debt basis and stock basis at the same time on a pro-rata basis until both reach zero together.
- BAgainst the corporation's own basis in its assets, since the loss originates at the entity level.
- CAgainst the shareholder's share of corporate-level liabilities owed to outside lenders, which create basis as in a partnership.
- DAgainst the shareholder's debt basis in the direct loan, but only after stock basis has been reduced to zero. Correct
Why A is wrong: Pro-rata absorption is tempting because both items are forms of basis, but the rules are strictly ordered: stock basis is reduced first and debt basis is used only for the loss that remains after stock basis hits zero.
Why B is wrong: This confuses inside basis with outside basis; loss limitation under Section 1366(d) operates on the shareholder's basis in stock and debt, not on the corporation's basis in its assets.
Why C is wrong: Unlike a partner, an S corporation shareholder gets no debt basis from the corporation's borrowing from third parties; only a bona fide loan made directly by the shareholder creates debt basis to absorb losses.
Why D is correct: Pass-through losses first reduce stock basis to zero and any remaining allowed loss then reduces the basis of debt the shareholder owes to the corporation, so debt basis absorbs the excess only after stock basis is exhausted.