Enrolled agent Maria Delgado prepared Victor Cho's 2024 return and took an aggressive deduction based on a position she knew had no reasonable basis, producing an understatement of tax. The Internal Revenue Service now wants to impose a monetary penalty on Maria for the understatement itself. Which regime authorises that particular monetary penalty, and who imposes it?
- AA Circular 230 monetary sanction under Section 10.50, imposed by the Office of Professional Responsibility after a disciplinary proceeding before an administrative law judge.
- BAn accuracy-related penalty under Section 6662, assessed against Maria as the preparer because the understatement was attributable to the position she advised.
- CThe Internal Revenue Code preparer penalty under Section 6694, assessed by the Internal Revenue Service like a tax, separate from any Office of Professional Responsibility sanction. Correct
- DA censure imposed by the Office of Professional Responsibility, which carries an automatic monetary fine set by Circular 230 for each understated return.
Why A is wrong: Circular 230 does authorise a monetary penalty under Section 10.50, which makes this tempting, but that disciplinary penalty addresses misconduct in practice and is separate from a penalty assessed for the understatement of tax itself, which is the Section 6694 preparer penalty assessed by the Service.
Why B is wrong: Section 6662 is an accuracy-related penalty, so it sounds relevant to an understatement, but it applies to the taxpayer for the underpayment, not to the return preparer; the preparer-specific penalty for an understatement from an unreasonable position is Section 6694.
Why C is correct: A monetary penalty on the preparer for an understatement arising from an unreasonable position is the Section 6694 preparer penalty, which the Service assesses and collects in the same manner as a tax; it is distinct from the disciplinary sanctions the Office of Professional Responsibility imposes under Circular 230.
Why D is wrong: Censure is a real Circular 230 sanction, so naming it is plausible, but censure is a public reprimand that carries no automatic fine, and the monetary penalty for the understatement itself flows from Section 6694, assessed by the Service rather than ordered as part of a censure.