CISA domain - 18% of the exam

Information Systems Auditing Process

Information Systems Auditing Process is 18% of the CISA exam. These are the objectives it covers, each with practice questions, with every answer explained.

The domain in numbers

51
Practice questions
4
Objectives
12
Easy
39
Medium

Where people go wrong

  • Anchoring the audit plan on history instead of current risk

    The wrong answers anchor the plan on something other than current risk: fixed-rotation cycles, follow-up of prior findings, auditor availability, a clean prior report, or the time since the last audit. Each is an input at most. The risk-based model ranks auditable units by inherent risk and control risk, then directs effort to the highest residual risk. A treasury workstation with a clean history but a fourfold rise in daily transaction value, or a settlement function unaudited for four years, ranks on present exposure.

    See it in a sample question
  • Accepting auditee-supplied material as sufficient evidence

    The wrong answers treat material supplied by the auditee as enough: a management self-assessment, a screenshot from the application owner, a written representation, or a report exported by the auditee. Each was prepared or selected by the party under review, so it cannot stand alone. The correct answers have the auditor obtain evidence directly, such as an independent extract from the production database or source system, reconciled to the auditee's version. Re-performance ranks highest for reliability.

    See it in a sample question
  • Matching the wrong sampling method to a control test

    The wrong answers pick a sampling method built for a different objective. Monetary unit sampling and variables sampling project monetary misstatement, discovery sampling suits low-tolerance cases where any occurrence matters, and judgemental selection cannot be projected to the population. Whether a control operated, such as a three-way match or approval by the correct line manager, is a yes or no question about each item. Attribute sampling, sized from the tolerable deviation rate, expected deviation rate and confidence level, estimates that deviation rate.

    See it in a sample question
  • Shrinking a finding instead of recording management's response

    The wrong answers shrink the report instead of recording both views: dropping a finding because remediation has started or a fix is promised, downgrading severity because the changes ran in production without incident or to ease acceptance, or withholding management's response until the owner agrees. The correct answers keep the finding at the severity the evidence supports and place management's response, remediation progress or alternative plan alongside it, so that those charged with governance see both positions.

    See it in a sample question
  • Managing an independence threat without disclosing it

    The wrong answers handle an independence threat with a measure that leaves it in place: documenting it, swapping the signing auditor, deferring the paid work, carving out vendor procedures, a confidentiality representation, peer re-performance, or escalating only after the work has started. None removes the self-review or self-interest threat. Under the Code of Professional Ethics the auditor discloses the threat to those charged with governance before fieldwork, and either declines the conflicting work or seeks reassignment or a documented safeguard, so that independence holds in fact and in appearance.

    See it in a sample question

Objectives in this domain

What to study

The official documents this domain's practice questions cite most.

Sample questions from this domain

Free sampleInformation Systems Auditing Processmedium

An IS auditor is risk-rating auditable units for the coming year. A treasury workstation has not changed in eighteen months, has a clean prior audit, and runs on a stable platform; however, market volatility has increased the daily transaction value through it by a factor of four. Which factor should weigh MOST heavily in the auditor's risk rating?

  • AThe fourfold rise in daily transaction value, which materially increases the inherent risk of the auditable unit. Correct
  • BThe clean prior-year audit report, which suggests the existing control environment continues to operate effectively.
  • CThe eighteen months since the last code change, which lowers the inherent risk of new defects entering the workstation.
  • DThe platform stability rating provided by the infrastructure team, which has not been downgraded during the period.
Risk-based planning must reflect current inherent risk drivers such as transaction value and volume, even when prior audit history and platform stability are favourable. ISACA guidance frames inherent risk as the susceptibility of an auditable unit to material misstatement or control failure before considering controls. A material change in transaction value directly increases potential impact, which is the dominant driver of inherent risk and therefore of the audit effort allocated to that unit.

Why A is correct: Inherent risk includes the financial and operational impact of a control failure; a sharp rise in transaction value raises that impact and should dominate the rating despite other stable factors.

Why B is wrong: A clean prior report is comforting but historical; risk ratings must reflect current exposure, and prior comfort does not offset a fourfold rise in transaction value.

Why C is wrong: Code stability reduces change-related risk, but inherent risk also tracks the value and volume processed; ignoring the volume increase understates exposure.

Why D is wrong: Platform stability addresses availability risk; it does not capture the materiality impact of much larger transaction values flowing through the same controls.

Free sampleInformation Systems Auditing Processmedium

While reviewing logical access to a general ledger, an IS auditor obtains a user-access report exported by the application owner from the production database. The auditor intends to use the report as primary evidence that segregation of duties was enforced during the year. What action would BEST strengthen the reliability of this evidence?

  • ARe-perform the user-access extract independently from the production database using the auditor's own query, then reconcile it to the application owner's report. Correct
  • BRequest a signed management representation that the exported report is complete and accurate as at the year-end reporting date for the general ledger system.
  • CCompare the user-access report to last year's equivalent report to confirm that the population size and role distribution are broadly consistent over time.
  • DIncrease the sample of users tested against approved access request forms so that any export omissions are more likely to be detected through expanded testing.
Apply the principle that evidence obtained directly by the IS auditor is more reliable than evidence prepared and supplied by the auditee. Reliability of audit evidence depends on its source and the auditor's degree of control over how it was produced. A report prepared by the auditee may be incomplete or filtered, intentionally or otherwise. Re-performing the extract from the source system using the auditor's own query and then reconciling to the auditee's report addresses completeness and accuracy together, giving a stronger basis for the segregation of duties conclusion.

Why A is correct: An auditor-controlled extraction reconciled to the auditee's report provides evidence obtained directly by the auditor, which is more reliable than evidence prepared by the auditee alone and addresses completeness and accuracy.

Why B is wrong: Management representations are corroborative only; relying on them as the primary support for an access conclusion does not address the risk that the underlying export was modified or filtered.

Why C is wrong: Year-on-year consistency is a useful analytical procedure but it does not establish that this year's report is complete or that segregation of duties operated; consistent populations can hide identical errors.

Why D is wrong: A larger sample does not address completeness of the population; if the report itself excludes users, those users have no chance of being selected, regardless of sample size.

Free sampleInformation Systems Auditing Processmedium

An IS audit team needs to estimate the deviation rate of an automated three-way match control across a population of fifty thousand purchase orders processed in the past year. Which sampling approach is MOST appropriate for this objective?

  • AMonetary unit sampling weighted by order value, with confidence and tolerable misstatement parameters drawn from the financial materiality calculated during overall audit planning.
  • BDiscovery sampling sized to detect at least one occurrence of a critical exception, with the engagement terminated as soon as the first exception is observed in the selected sample.
  • CJudgemental selection of high-value orders flagged by management as sensitive, supplemented by haphazard selection from quieter weeks in the year covered by the audit period.
  • DAttribute sampling, with the sample size derived from the expected deviation rate, the tolerable deviation rate, and the desired confidence level appropriate to a test of operating effectiveness. Correct
Select attribute sampling when the audit objective is to estimate the deviation rate of a control across a defined population. Attribute sampling is the sampling method aligned with tests of controls because it estimates the rate of occurrence of a binary attribute, such as whether an exception was correctly handled. Monetary unit and discovery sampling answer different objectives, and judgemental selection cannot support a statistical projection of the deviation rate.

Why A is wrong: Tempting because monetary unit sampling is common in financial audit, but the objective here is to estimate a control deviation rate, not to project a monetary misstatement across the population.

Why B is wrong: Discovery sampling fits low-tolerance settings where any occurrence is significant, such as suspected fraud, but it does not produce an estimated deviation rate across the population for a routine control test.

Why C is wrong: This is non-statistical and biased toward known concerns, so it cannot support a quantitative conclusion about the control's deviation rate across the population.

Why D is correct: Attribute sampling is designed to estimate a rate of occurrence of a binary attribute, which is exactly what a test of an automated control's exception rate measures.

Free sampleInformation Systems Auditing Processmedium

During fieldwork on a change management audit, the IS auditor identifies that two emergency changes to a customer-facing pricing engine bypassed the standard approval workflow and were not retrospectively reviewed. Production logs confirm both changes ran for over a week before being detected. How should the IS auditor BEST handle this finding before the closing meeting?

  • AInclude the finding in the draft report immediately and notify the audit committee chair the same day so they can decide whether to escalate the matter to the board.
  • BRemove the finding from the draft report once the change manager commits verbally to backfilling the missing approvals for both emergency changes within the next week.
  • CReclassify the finding as an informational observation because the changes have already run successfully in production for more than a week without any reported incidents.
  • DDiscuss the observation with the change manager, obtain their written response and confirm the underlying evidence before including the finding in the draft audit report. Correct
Confirm the facts with the responsible auditee and obtain a management response before issuing a finding in the audit report. The auditor reports findings to those charged with governance only after the facts have been confirmed with the responsible auditee and a management response has been obtained. This sequence protects the accuracy of the report, gives the auditee an opportunity to correct misunderstandings, and produces a report that records both the finding and management's planned action, which is the basis on which the audit committee will track remediation.

Why A is wrong: Direct escalation to the audit committee chair before the auditee has confirmed the facts bypasses the normal reporting line and risks reporting an inaccurate or incomplete finding.

Why B is wrong: A verbal remediation commitment does not erase the control deficiency that operated during the audit period; the finding still needs to be reported with the management response.

Why C is wrong: Successful operation in production does not justify downgrading severity; the absence of approval and retrospective review is the control failure being reported.

Why D is correct: Validating the facts with the responsible manager and securing a management response before reporting maintains accuracy, supports auditee due process, and aligns with ITAF reporting requirements.

Free sampleInformation Systems Auditing Processmedium

An IS auditor has just been assigned to lead the annual review of an insurer's policy administration platform. During scoping, the head of internal audit mentions that the auditor's spouse joined the platform's vendor as a senior account manager three weeks ago, with commission tied to renewal of the insurer's licence. What should the IS auditor do FIRST?

  • AContinue with the engagement but exclude vendor-related procedures and document the carve-out in the working papers for transparency.
  • BProceed with the audit and rely on a peer reviewer to re-perform any findings that relate directly to the vendor's contractual obligations.
  • CDisclose the relationship in writing to those charged with audit governance and seek reassignment or a documented independence safeguard before fieldwork begins. Correct
  • DObtain a signed representation from the spouse that no confidential audit information will be shared and retain it in the permanent audit file.
Recognise that a close family financial interest in an auditee's vendor must be disclosed to governance before fieldwork to preserve independence. Independence under the ISACA code is judged in fact and in appearance. A spouse earning commission tied to the audited platform's continued use creates a self-interest threat that disclosure to those charged with governance, followed by reassignment or a documented safeguard, is designed to resolve before any audit evidence is gathered.

Why A is wrong: Carving out vendor procedures still leaves the auditor opining on a platform whose continued use benefits a related party financially, so the appearance of independence is not restored by scope reduction alone.

Why B is wrong: Peer re-performance is a useful quality control but it does not address the underlying conflict of interest, which must be disclosed and governed before fieldwork rather than mitigated retrospectively.

Why C is correct: ISACA's code requires the auditor to disclose any relationship that could impair independence in fact or appearance and let governance decide on reassignment or a safeguard, which preserves both objectivity and the engagement's credibility.

Why D is wrong: A confidentiality representation addresses information leakage only, while the threat here is to objectivity and appearance of independence, which a personal undertaking cannot resolve.

Other domains in this exam

See also the CISA cert hub, the study guide, and the cheat sheet.

Examworthy is not affiliated with or endorsed by ISACA. Original, blueprint-aligned practice material only.