An IS auditor is risk-rating auditable units for the coming year. A treasury workstation has not changed in eighteen months, has a clean prior audit, and runs on a stable platform; however, market volatility has increased the daily transaction value through it by a factor of four. Which factor should weigh MOST heavily in the auditor's risk rating?
- AThe fourfold rise in daily transaction value, which materially increases the inherent risk of the auditable unit. Correct
- BThe clean prior-year audit report, which suggests the existing control environment continues to operate effectively.
- CThe eighteen months since the last code change, which lowers the inherent risk of new defects entering the workstation.
- DThe platform stability rating provided by the infrastructure team, which has not been downgraded during the period.
Why A is correct: Inherent risk includes the financial and operational impact of a control failure; a sharp rise in transaction value raises that impact and should dominate the rating despite other stable factors.
Why B is wrong: A clean prior report is comforting but historical; risk ratings must reflect current exposure, and prior comfort does not offset a fourfold rise in transaction value.
Why C is wrong: Code stability reduces change-related risk, but inherent risk also tracks the value and volume processed; ignoring the volume increase understates exposure.
Why D is wrong: Platform stability addresses availability risk; it does not capture the materiality impact of much larger transaction values flowing through the same controls.