An IS auditor is classifying controls on a corporate network. A next generation firewall is configured to permit only explicitly allowed flows between segments and to drop everything else by default. How should the auditor BEST characterise this control?
- AA detective control because the firewall logs every dropped connection and feeds those events to the security information and event management platform
- BA preventive control because the default deny posture stops disallowed traffic from reaching the destination before any policy violation can occur Correct
- CA corrective control because the firewall closes a known vulnerability in the destination service by terminating the offending session midstream
- DA compensating control because the firewall substitutes for absent application layer authentication that the destination service cannot enforce on its own
Why A is wrong: Logging is a detective by product, but the primary function described in the stem is the default deny enforcement that blocks traffic before it reaches the destination; characterising the control by its log output understates its preventive role.
Why B is correct: A preventive control acts before an event, and a firewall configured with explicit allow and default deny blocks unauthorised flows at the boundary so they never reach the protected segment; this matches the textbook definition of a preventive control.
Why C is wrong: Corrective controls remediate after an event has occurred, such as restoring data from backup; the firewall described in the stem does not repair anything, so labelling it corrective misapplies the control category vocabulary.
Why D is wrong: A compensating control is selected when a required primary control cannot be implemented and a substitute provides equivalent assurance; the stem does not state any missing primary control, so this option imports a justification that is not present.