An organisation has only limited historical loss data and the board wants a fast view of how several new technology risks rank against one another. Which characteristic makes a qualitative analysis the more defensible choice than a quantitative one in this situation?
- AIt produces a precise monetary loss figure for each risk, so the board can compare exposures directly against the annual control budget in currency terms.
- BIt removes analyst judgement from the rating, so two independent assessors will always arrive at exactly the same ranking for every risk.
- CIt expresses likelihood and impact on ordinal scales, so relative ranking is possible without the reliable loss frequencies a quantitative model demands. Correct
- DIt calculates an annualised loss expectancy for each risk, so a return on the security investment can be derived directly from the ratings.
Why A is wrong: Producing precise monetary figures is the strength of quantitative analysis, not qualitative, so this attributes the wrong capability to the chosen method.
Why B is wrong: Qualitative analysis relies heavily on subjective judgement and does not guarantee identical results, so claiming it removes judgement is the opposite of the truth.
Why C is correct: Qualitative analysis uses ordinal high, medium and low scales to rank risks relative to each other, which suits sparse data where credible numeric frequencies are unavailable.
Why D is wrong: Annualised loss expectancy and return on security investment are outputs of quantitative analysis, so attaching them to a qualitative method confuses the two approaches.