A bank is rebuilding the perimeter for a sensitive payments environment. The architect must choose between traditional VLAN-based segmentation and identity-aware micro-segmentation. Which statement BEST distinguishes micro-segmentation from VLAN segmentation in a defensible design?
- AMicro-segmentation enforces policy per workload identity and on east-west traffic, whereas VLAN segmentation primarily isolates broadcast domains and relies on a separate firewall for inter-VLAN policy. Correct
- BMicro-segmentation always replaces firewalls and removes the need for an Internet edge filter once it is deployed.
- CMicro-segmentation is implemented only by SDN controllers and cannot be enforced at the host level.
- DMicro-segmentation operates exclusively at layer 2 to isolate broadcast domains for individual virtual machines.
Why A is correct: Micro-segmentation applies fine-grained policy keyed to workload, user, or process identity and inspects lateral traffic between peers in the same broadcast domain, while VLANs create layer 2 broadcast separation and depend on an external layer 3 device to filter between VLANs, which is the load-bearing distinction in design reviews.
Why B is wrong: This is tempting because vendor messaging often positions micro-segmentation as a replacement for perimeter tools, but it complements rather than replaces edge firewalls and IDS. Treating it as a wholesale replacement leaves north-south traffic unprotected and is not the way the control is positioned in CISSP-aligned architectures.
Why C is wrong: Many candidates remember that SDN enables micro-segmentation and conclude the controller is mandatory. In practice host-based agents, hypervisor distributed firewalls, and identity-aware proxies can all enforce micro-segmentation without a centralised SDN fabric, so this option is too narrow.
Why D is wrong: Confining micro-segmentation to layer 2 mirrors how VLANs work and sounds plausible, but micro-segmentation typically inspects layer 3 to layer 7 attributes and is identity-aware, not broadcast-domain-aware, so this description actually re-describes VLANs.