A risk manager is reviewing a proposed federation in which a global supplier will act as identity provider for staff signing into the organisation's procurement portal. Which residual risk is MOST important to address through contractual and technical controls because it cannot be removed simply by adopting a federation protocol?
- AThe choice of SAML over OpenID Connect introduces XML signature wrapping vulnerabilities that cannot be mitigated by any relying party configuration.
- BThe federation will introduce a circular trust between the identity provider and the resource server that prevents revocation of access tokens once issued.
- CAdopting a federation protocol forces the relying party to accept the identity provider's encryption ciphers for data at rest within the procurement portal.
- DThe relying party must accept the identity provider's account lifecycle and authentication assurance, so a weak joiner-mover-leaver process at the supplier directly affects portal access. Correct
Why A is wrong: XML signature wrapping is a real implementation risk with SAML, but it can be mitigated by hardened parsers, strict schema validation, and library updates. It is not the dominant residual risk in this scenario.
Why B is wrong: Federation does not create circular trust between identity provider and resource server. Token revocation is a real challenge for bearer tokens, but it can be addressed with short lifetimes and introspection, and it is not unique to this federation.
Why C is wrong: Federation governs authentication and assertions, not data-at-rest encryption in the relying party. The relying party retains control of its own storage cryptography, so this is not a residual federation risk.
Why D is correct: Federation moves authentication and the account lifecycle to the identity provider, so the relying party inherits whatever assurance and offboarding rigour the supplier applies. Contractual obligations and technical signals such as session timeouts and back-channel logout are required to manage this transferred risk.