Dana, 35, has non-discretionary monthly living expenses of 6,200 dollars. Her accounts hold 9,400 dollars in chequing, 22,600 dollars in a savings account and 12,000 dollars in a money market fund, all available on demand without penalty. She also has 60,000 dollars in her employer 401(k), from which any withdrawal before age 59 and a half would be taxable and penalised, and an untouched home equity line of credit with 15,000 dollars of available borrowing. Measuring her emergency fund in months of non-discretionary expenses covered by liquid assets, what figure should the planner report?
- A5.2 months
- B7.1 months Correct
- C9.5 months
- D16.8 months
Why A is wrong: This counts only the 9,400 dollar chequing and 22,600 dollar savings balances, giving 32,000 dollars divided by 6,200 dollars. The money market fund is available on demand without penalty and therefore belongs in liquid assets.
Why B is correct: Liquid assets of 9,400 plus 22,600 plus 12,000 come to 44,000 dollars, and 44,000 divided by 6,200 is 7.1 months, using only assets Dana can convert to cash immediately without tax or penalty.
Why C is wrong: This adds the 15,000 dollars of available credit on the home equity line to the 44,000 dollars of liquid assets. Unused borrowing capacity is not an asset the client owns, and a lender can reduce or freeze the line at the moment it is needed.
Why D is wrong: This adds the 60,000 dollar 401(k) balance to the 44,000 dollars of liquid assets. A retirement account reachable only through a taxable and penalised early withdrawal fails the liquidity test used for an emergency fund measure.