Marta is 56 and owns a dental practice that produces 600,000 dollars of net income a year after paying staff. She employs three hygienists and a receptionist, all aged between 27 and 34 and earning modest salaries. Marta has saved little for retirement, has stable and predictable profits, and tells her planner that her single objective is the largest annual deductible contribution the tax rules will allow for her own benefit, accepting that she must also cover her staff. Which plan design best meets that objective?
- AA SEP arrangement, because the employer may contribute up to 25 percent of each eligible person's pay
- BA SIMPLE IRA, because it avoids the cost and testing burden of a qualified plan for a small practice
- CA cash balance defined benefit plan paired with a 401(k) profit sharing plan for her own deferrals Correct
- DA profit sharing plan alone, because the contribution is discretionary each year and deductible
Why A is wrong: A SEP is easy to run and generous relative to a SIMPLE, but the contribution percentage must be uniform across eligible participants and is capped by the annual additions limit, so it cannot single out an older owner.
Why B is wrong: A SIMPLE IRA has the lowest deferral ceiling of the small business plans and a fixed employer match, so it delivers far less for the owner than either a profit sharing design or a defined benefit design.
Why C is correct: A cash balance plan sets contributions actuarially from an age based benefit target, so an owner of 56 funding over a short horizon can receive far more than the defined contribution annual additions limit permits.
Why D is wrong: A profit sharing plan gives welcome flexibility and can be cross tested by age, but every participant's allocation is still bounded by the defined contribution annual additions limit, which caps what the owner can receive.