Marta, aged 62, bought 1,000 shares of a listed company years ago for 90,000 dollars in total. When the shares had fallen to a total fair market value of 60,000 dollars she gave all 1,000 to her daughter Ines, and no gift tax was paid on the transfer. Nineteen months later Ines sold the entire block for 75,000 dollars. What does Ines report on the sale?
- AA long term capital gain of 15,000 dollars, using the 60,000 dollar value of the shares on the date of the gift as her basis
- BNeither a gain nor a loss, because the 75,000 dollar sale price falls between the 60,000 dollar loss basis and the 90,000 dollar gain basis Correct
- CA long term capital loss of 15,000 dollars, using the 90,000 dollar basis her mother had in the shares before the gift
- DA long term capital gain of 15,000 dollars, reduced to nil by the unused 30,000 dollar decline in value that accrued while her mother owned the shares
Why A is wrong: This applies the fair market value at the date of gift as a single basis for every purpose, which is tempting because that figure is the lower of the two. The 60,000 dollar figure is the basis for measuring a loss and cannot be used to create a gain, so no 15,000 dollar gain arises.
Why B is correct: Correct. Under the dual basis rule the donor's 90,000 dollar basis measures gain and the 60,000 dollar value at the date of gift measures loss. A sale at 75,000 dollars produces no gain against the first figure and no loss against the second, so the result is nil.
Why C is wrong: Carryover basis is the correct starting point for a gift, so reaching for the donor's 90,000 dollars is a reasonable instinct. Where the value at the date of gift is below the donor's basis, the donor's basis measures gain and cannot be used to claim a loss, so no 15,000 dollar loss arises.
Why D is wrong: This reaches the right nil outcome by inventing a transfer of the donor's unrealised decline to the donee. No such carryover of a built in loss exists for an ordinary lifetime gift, and describing the result as an offset gain misstates what Ines reports.