Aisling is 54 and owns a universal life contract she funded with large single premiums in its early years, so the contract failed the seven-pay test and is a modified endowment contract. Her adjusted basis in the contract is 150,000 dollars and the cash value is now 260,000 dollars. She takes a 40,000 dollar cash withdrawal to help fund a house deposit and keeps the policy in force. Assuming no exception to the additional tax applies, how is the withdrawal taxed to her?
- ANone of the 40,000 dollars is taxable, because a withdrawal from a life policy recovers premiums paid before any gain, and no additional tax applies.
- BAll 40,000 dollars is ordinary income, but no additional tax applies because distributions from life cover sit outside the early distribution rules.
- CAll 40,000 dollars is ordinary income, and a further 4,000 dollars additional tax applies because Aisling is under 59 and a half. Correct
- D16,923 dollars is ordinary income, being the 110,000 dollars gain spread pro rata across the 260,000 dollars of cash value.
Why A is wrong: This is the correct answer for a contract that is not a modified endowment contract, where withdrawals are recovered first out of investment in the contract. Once the seven-pay test is failed that first in first out ordering is switched off, so basis recovery does not come first.
Why B is wrong: The ordering half of this is right, and it is tempting because ordinary life insurance withdrawals genuinely carry no age based penalty. Modified endowment contract distributions are the exception: the taxable amount attracts the 10 per cent additional tax unless the owner is 59 and a half, disabled, or taking a life annuity.
Why C is correct: A modified endowment contract distributes on a last in first out basis, so the whole withdrawal comes out of the 110,000 dollars of gain and is ordinary income. The 10 per cent additional tax on the taxable amount adds 4,000 dollars because she is under 59 and a half and no exception applies.
Why D is wrong: This borrows the exclusion ratio used for annuitised payments and applies it to a lump sum withdrawal. A pre-annuitisation withdrawal is not prorated between basis and gain, so no exclusion ratio arises here.