How is the Section 6695(g) due-diligence penalty applied when a single return claims more than one covered tax benefit, such as the earned income tax credit, the child tax credit, and head of household filing status?
- AA single penalty is imposed for the whole return regardless of how many covered benefits appear on it, because the law treats the entire return as one due-diligence engagement for the taxpayer.
- BA penalty is imposed only for the single covered benefit that produced the largest tax saving, since the Service pursues the failure with the greatest revenue effect rather than each one separately.
- CA separate penalty may be imposed for each covered tax benefit on which the preparer failed to meet the due-diligence requirements, so failures on several benefits on one return can produce several penalties. Correct
- DNo penalty is imposed where at least one covered benefit on the return was handled with proper due diligence, because compliance on any one benefit shields the preparer for the remaining benefits.
Why A is wrong: Treating the return as one engagement is intuitive, but the penalty is assessed for each covered benefit on which due diligence fails, so capping it at one charge per return understates how the penalty applies.
Why B is wrong: Focusing on the largest benefit sounds like sensible enforcement triage, but the penalty applies to each failure regardless of the size of the benefit, so limiting it to the most valuable credit is wrong.
Why C is correct: The due-diligence requirements apply to each covered benefit individually, so a preparer who fails them as to the earned income credit, the child tax credit, and head of household status on one return can be penalised separately for each, which this statement captures.
Why D is wrong: A safe-harbour for partial compliance would be convenient, but doing due diligence on one benefit does not excuse failures on the others, so this protective rule does not exist.