A retailer has decided to retire a fleet of point-of-sale tablets that processed cardholder data. The operations director proposes donating the tablets to a local school after a factory reset, arguing that the reset removes all customer data. As the security manager advising on disposal, what is the BEST course of action?
- ADecline the donation and require purge or destruction aligned to the cardholder data classification, with documented evidence Correct
- BApprove the donation after verifying the factory reset completes successfully on each tablet
- CApprove the donation after wiping the tablets with a single-pass overwrite of the user partition
- DApprove the donation provided the school signs a data protection agreement accepting any residual data
Why A is correct: Cardholder data attracts a high handling standard, and once the device is leaving the organisation's control the residual risk must be reduced to negligible. Purge or destruction with documented evidence is the defensible position and aligns with both PCI DSS and recognised media sanitisation guidance.
Why B is wrong: A factory reset is not a recognised sanitisation method for media that held cardholder data. Residual data can often be recovered, so verifying the reset succeeded does not raise the assurance to the level the data classification requires.
Why C is wrong: A single-pass overwrite of the user partition leaves system and cache areas, and on flash storage wear-levelling can mean overwritten blocks remain readable. It is below the assurance standard expected for cardholder data leaving the organisation's control.
Why D is wrong: Transferring residual cardholder data to a third party under contract does not satisfy the organisation's own obligations under the card scheme rules or data protection law. The risk cannot be contracted away to a recipient that is not a payment environment.