A secondary school teacher has 90 end-of-year reports to write in two weeks. The school's AI-use policy allows staff to use Claude to draft text but prohibits entering pupils' names, special educational needs details or other identifying information. The teacher's notes on each pupil include all of these. What should the teacher do?
- APaste the notes in full, but instruct Claude not to store or reuse any pupil information once the reports are finished
- BRemove identifying details from the notes, use Claude to draft the wording, then add specifics and check each report by hand Correct
- CWrite all 90 reports by hand, because any use of Claude on pupil reports breaches the school's AI-use policy
- DPaste the notes with names replaced by initials, since initials alone are not enough to identify a pupil
Why A is wrong: Asking Claude to forget the data feels like a safeguard. But the policy forbids entering the information at all, and an instruction to the model is not a control that undoes having shared it.
Why B is correct: Drafting report wording is a permitted use, and stripping identifying details first keeps the input within policy. Adding the specifics and checking each report afterwards keeps the teacher accountable for what parents read.
Why C is wrong: Avoiding the tool entirely feels like the safest reading of the policy. But the policy allows drafting, so giving up over-corrects when removing the identifying details would make the task permitted.
Why D is wrong: Swapping names for initials looks like anonymisation. But the special educational needs details are still included, which the policy prohibits, and initials combined with class details can still identify a pupil.