An HR adviser at a logistics company pastes a two-page absence policy into a chat and asks Claude to 'make this better'. The result is longer and more formal than the original. The summary is for warehouse shift workers who will read it on their phones during breaks, and many of them speak English as a second language. Which change to the request is most likely to fix the problem?
- ARepeat the request with stronger wording, such as 'make this much better and far more professional'.
- BUpload the company's other HR policies so Claude has more background on how the organisation writes.
- CState the audience, ask for plain language under 200 words, and list the key actions as short bullet points. Correct
- DAsk Claude to produce five alternative versions so the adviser can choose the one that reads best.
Why A is wrong: Emphasis can feel like a way to signal dissatisfaction. It is wrong because it is still vague, and 'more professional' pushes the text further towards the formal style that already failed this audience.
Why B is wrong: More background sometimes helps, so this looks like adding context. It is wrong because the missing information is about the readers and the format, and formal policy documents would reinforce the long, formal style rather than correct it.
Why C is correct: The request never said who the summary was for or what 'better' meant, so Claude read it as more polished and complete. Naming the audience, the reading level, a length and a scannable format gives Claude a clear target that matches shift workers reading on phones.
Why D is wrong: Choosing from several drafts seems efficient. It is wrong because all five versions start from the same unclear request, so the adviser is likely to get five variations on the wrong target.