A fitness app operator wants to lawfully process users' heart-rate and sleep data, which it concedes reveals information about their health. Its terms already establish performance of the service contract as the lawful basis under Article 6. To process this health data lawfully, what must the operator additionally establish?
- AA separate condition under Article 9(2), because health data is a special category and contractual necessity is not itself one of the listed Article 9(2) exceptions. Correct
- BNothing further, because once a valid Article 6 lawful basis exists, processing of any category of personal data necessary to perform that contract is permitted.
- CA data protection impact assessment, which once completed and documented removes the Article 9 prohibition for the health data being processed.
- DCertification under an approved Article 42 scheme, which serves as the qualifying exception that legitimises processing of the special category health data.
Why A is correct: Correct: Article 9(1) prohibits processing special category data unless an Article 9(2) condition applies, and performance of a contract is not among them, so an Article 9(2) condition must be identified in addition to the Article 6 basis.
Why B is wrong: This is tempting because contractual necessity is a complete Article 6 basis, but special category data needs a separate Article 9(2) condition layered on top of the Article 6 basis; the two articles operate cumulatively.
Why C is wrong: A DPIA is tempting because health data processing often triggers Article 35, but a DPIA assesses and mitigates risk and never functions as a lawful condition that lifts the Article 9(1) prohibition.
Why D is wrong: Certification is plausible as a compliance signal, but Article 42 certification demonstrates adherence to the Regulation and is not a listed Article 9(2) condition that permits special category processing.