A Belgian retailer collected email addresses at the point of sale when customers bought a kitchen blender. Six months later it wants to email those same customers about a new range of food processors it sells, without having asked at purchase whether they wished to receive marketing. Which condition is decisive in determining whether the retailer may send these emails without separate prior consent under the ePrivacy regime?
- AWhether the retailer has carried out a legitimate interests assessment showing that the commercial benefit to the business outweighs the privacy intrusion to the affected customers.
- BWhether the food processors are similar products to the blender the customer originally bought and the customer was given an opportunity to object both at collection and in each message. Correct
- CWhether the customers are existing customers of the retailer rather than prospects, which alone is sufficient to permit the emails under the soft opt-in.
- DWhether the retailer can demonstrate that the emails are sent no more frequently than once per calendar month to each recipient on the list.
Why A is wrong: A legitimate interests balancing test is a familiar GDPR lawful basis and is tempting, but unsolicited electronic marketing is governed by the specific ePrivacy consent rules, so a legitimate interests assessment does not by itself authorise the emails.
Why B is correct: The ePrivacy Directive's soft opt-in exception permits marketing to existing customers about similar products where the address was obtained in the context of a sale and a free right to object is offered at collection and in every communication, which is exactly what governs this case.
Why C is wrong: Existing-customer status is necessary but not sufficient; candidates often stop at this point, yet the exception also requires product similarity and a right to object at collection and in each message, so this answer is incomplete.
Why D is wrong: A frequency cap sounds like a reasonable safeguard and may feature in good practice, but no such numeric limit is the decisive legal condition under the soft opt-in, which turns on similarity, context of sale, and the right to object.