A market-research firm based outside the EU recruits a panel of consumers who are located in several Member States and asks them to install an app that continuously records which websites they visit and how long they spend on each, in order to analyse and predict their consumption habits over time. The firm has no office, staff, or servers anywhere in the EU. Which limb of Article 3 brings this processing within the GDPR, and why?
- AArticle 3(1), because installing an app on user devices located in the EU creates a stable arrangement that amounts to an establishment of the firm in each Member State concerned.
- BArticle 3(3), because the firm processes the data of EU residents in a place where Member State law applies by virtue of public international law, such as a flagged vessel.
- CArticle 3(2)(b), because tracking and analysing the panellists' online behaviour over time monitors the behaviour of data subjects that takes place within the Union. Correct
- DArticle 3(2)(a), because asking the panellists to install the app and join the panel amounts to offering them a service within the Union.
Why A is wrong: An app running on a user's own device does not give the firm stable arrangements of its own in the Member State; Article 3(1) needs an establishment of the controller, which the firm plainly lacks here.
Why B is wrong: Article 3(3) addresses narrow situations such as embassies or ships under a Member State flag where national law applies through international law; it has nothing to do with commercial behavioural tracking of consumers.
Why C is correct: Continuous tracking of browsing to profile and predict habits is precisely the behavioural monitoring of data subjects in the Union that Article 3(2)(b) targets, and it applies to non-EU controllers with no EU establishment.
Why D is wrong: Tempting because the panel is recruited, but the operative feature is the ongoing monitoring of behaviour, not an offer of goods or services for which the offering limb in Article 3(2)(a) is designed.