A detective investigating a fraud ring serves a subpoena on a webmail provider seeking only a target account's basic subscriber information: the subscriber's name, the address on file, the dates the account was opened and closed, and the means and source of payment. The detective does not want the body of any message or any record of who the target emailed. Under the Stored Communications Act, which process does the government need to compel this specific category of records from the provider?
- AA probable-cause search warrant, because any compelled disclosure from a webmail provider implicates the subscriber's reasonable expectation of privacy in the account.
- BA court order issued on specific and articulable facts under section 2703(d), because all non-content subscriber records require that intermediate standard before a provider may disclose them.
- CAn administrative, grand jury, or trial subpoena, because basic subscriber and billing information is the lowest tier of stored records and is reachable with a subpoena under the Stored Communications Act. Correct
- DA pen register and trap-and-trace order, because the requested account details are dialling and addressing information rather than communication content.
Why A is wrong: Tempting because Warshak requires a warrant for message content, but basic subscriber information is non-content; the SCA lets the government reach it with a subpoena, so a warrant is more process than the statute demands here.
Why B is wrong: Tempting because the 2703(d) order governs many non-content transactional records, but the enumerated basic subscriber and billing items in 2703(c)(2) sit a tier below and are obtainable with a mere subpoena.
Why C is correct: Correct: section 2703(c)(2) lists name, address, length and dates of service, and means and source of payment as records a provider must disclose in response to a subpoena, the lowest of the SCA process tiers.
Why D is wrong: Tempting because pen registers capture non-content addressing data, but they collect prospective dialled or routing data in real time, not historical stored subscriber records like the name and payment details requested here.