Proponents of the information fiduciary model criticise the prevailing notice-and-choice approach to US consumer privacy. A platform defends its data practices by pointing to a clear privacy notice and a checkbox by which users consented. From the information fiduciary perspective, what is the central weakness in relying on that notice and consent to legitimise the practices?
- AUsers face take-it-or-leave-it terms they cannot meaningfully negotiate or understand, so consent does not reflect a real choice and cannot license a firm to act against the users' interests. Correct
- BNotice and consent are invalid because federal law requires written wet-ink signatures rather than electronic checkboxes for any consent to data processing.
- CNotice and consent fail only when the notice is materially false, so a truthful notice would fully resolve the information fiduciary objection to the practices.
- DConsent is irrelevant because the information fiduciary model would ban all collection of personal data regardless of what users agree to.
Why A is correct: Correct: the model argues that notice-and-choice rests on a fiction of informed agreement, because users confront non-negotiable terms they cannot realistically read or bargain over, so a click cannot authorise the firm to use the data in ways that harm them, which is why a loyalty duty is proposed instead.
Why B is wrong: Tempting because consent formalities matter in some contexts, but there is no general federal rule voiding electronic consent for data processing, so the critique does not rest on a signature-format defect.
Why C is wrong: Tempting because a false notice does create separate exposure, but the information fiduciary critique applies even to truthful notices, so saying accuracy alone cures the objection misses the model's deeper point about loyalty.
Why D is wrong: Tempting because the model is protective of users, but it does not propose banning data collection outright, only constraining disloyal use, so portraying it as a blanket prohibition overstates the position.