A knowledge base lists user criteria matching all permanent employees on its Can Read list, and separate user criteria matching contractors on its Cannot Read list. A contractor who is also a permanent employee record holder matches both sets of criteria. What determines the outcome for that user?
- AThe user gains read access, because a matching entry on the Can Read list is evaluated after the exclusion list
- BThe user gains read access, because user criteria matching is additive and any single match is sufficient
- CThe user is denied read access, because a match on the Cannot Read list takes precedence over a match on Can Read Correct
- DThe user gains read access, because the criteria are compared and the one matching more attributes takes effect
Why A is wrong: It is tempting to assume the inclusion list runs last and therefore wins, but the exclusion list is what settles a conflict, so access is denied rather than granted.
Why B is wrong: Multiple criteria on one list are indeed additive, so this reasoning is half right, yet it ignores that the Cannot Read list exists precisely to remove users the inclusion list would otherwise admit.
Why C is correct: The exclusion lists are designed to override the inclusion lists, so any user matching Cannot Read is kept out of the knowledge base regardless of another match.
Why D is wrong: Specificity decides the winner among access control rules on some platforms, which makes this feel familiar, but knowledge user criteria are not scored against each other by attribute count.