Harbourview University is modernising its student portal. The programme manager, Aisha, assumes the current monitoring tooling is worthless and plans to replace it wholesale, but a colleague argues she is misapplying Start where you are. What is the strongest reason her colleague is right?
- AStart where you are forbids replacing any existing tool, because the principle requires organisations to retain whatever is already in place.
- BStart where you are calls for measuring and assessing the existing tooling first, because some current elements may be reusable and worth carrying forward. Correct
- CStart where you are means change should only ever be made in small increments, so a wholesale tooling replacement is prohibited by definition.
- DStart where you are means new tooling must be chosen by the consumers of the service, because they alone decide what the current state is worth.
Why A is wrong: Tempting as an overcorrection, but the principle does not forbid replacement; it requires assessment first, and tools with no remaining value can still be retired.
Why B is correct: The principle requires examining the current state before deciding what to keep or replace, precisely so that valuable existing components are not thrown away on assumption.
Why C is wrong: Incremental progress is a separate guiding principle; conflating it with Start where you are misidentifies why Aisha's approach is flawed.
Why D is wrong: Consumer perspective belongs to Focus on value; Start where you are is about assessing the current state directly, not handing tool selection to consumers.