The Ashford Interchange project reports earned value of 250,000 pounds, planned value of 300,000 pounds, and actual cost of 275,000 pounds at the monthly review. Which statement correctly interprets both the schedule variance and the cost variance together?
- AThe project is ahead of schedule and under budget, so no corrective action is needed.
- BThe project is behind schedule but under budget by 25,000 pounds against the plan.
- CThe project is over budget but ahead of schedule by 50,000 pounds against the plan.
- DThe project is behind schedule by 50,000 pounds and over budget by 25,000 pounds. Correct
Why A is wrong: This flips the sign of both variances; earned value sits below both planned value and actual cost, so the project is behind schedule and over budget, not ahead and under.
Why B is wrong: The schedule reading is right but the cost reading is reversed; actual cost of 275,000 exceeds earned value of 250,000, so cost variance is minus 25,000 pounds, meaning over budget rather than under.
Why C is wrong: The cost reading is right but the schedule reading is reversed; earned value of 250,000 is below planned value of 300,000, so schedule variance is minus 50,000 pounds, meaning behind schedule rather than ahead.
Why D is correct: Schedule variance is earned value minus planned value, 250,000 minus 300,000, giving minus 50,000 pounds behind; cost variance is earned value minus actual cost, 250,000 minus 275,000, giving minus 25,000 pounds over, so both variances are negative.